- American Family vs. Erie: Which one is the cheapest?
- American Family vs. Erie: Rates by age group
- American Family vs. Erie: Rates for high-risk drivers
- American Family vs. Erie: Rates in your state
- American Family vs. Erie: Which offers better discounts?
- American Family vs. Erie: The bottom line
- Methodology
American Family vs. Erie: Which one is the cheapest?
Erie costs an average of $346, while American Family has average rates for state minimum coverage of $602.
For full coverage with 100/300/100 in liability coverage and $500 deductibles for comprehensive and collision insurance, Erie costs an average of $1,480. American Family costs more at an average of $1,698.
It’s always a good idea to shop around for quotes, however, because prices and coverage vary from state to state and depend on your individual situation.
| Company | Average annual rate for full coverage | Average annual rate for state minimum coverage | Average annual premium for liability-only car insurance |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Family | $1,698 | $602 | $870 |
| Erie | $1,480 | $346 | $415 |
American Family vs. Erie: Rates by age group
For a teen – one of the most expensive age groups to insure – Erie has the cheapest rates, coming in at $3,737 per year. American Family costs an average of $4,515 for a teen driver.
Age is a major factor in calculating insurance rates. Companies look at speeding and accident trends as well as distracted driving statistics. Teen drivers are one of the riskiest – and therefore most expensive – age groups to insure. Rates drop as you get older.
For example, adults pay an average of $1,494 at Erie, while at American Family the average rate for an adult is $1,701.
| Age (group) | American Family | Erie |
|---|---|---|
| Teens | $4,515 | $3,737 |
| Young adults | $2,424 | $2,369 |
| Adults | $1,701 | $1,494 |
| Seniors | $1,813 | $1,541 |
American Family vs. Erie: Rates for high-risk drivers
Erie has the best rates for high-risk drivers. A high-risk driver is someone who has multiple speeding tickets, accidents or a serious offense like a DUI on their record. This can make it a challenge to find affordable auto insurance.
For the drivers with DUI, Erie is cheaper, with average rates of $2,869.
Take a look at the table below for American Family’s rates compared to Erie’s rates.
| Type of violation | American Family | Erie |
|---|---|---|
| 1 At-fault property damage accident over $2K | $2,447 | $2,046 |
| 1 At-fault property damage accident under $2K | $2,447 | $1,970 |
| At-fault bodily injury accident | $2,542 | $2,079 |
| Careless driving | $2,205 | $1,728 |
| DUI | $2,908 | $2,869 |
| Reckless driving | $2,805 | $1,908 |
| Speeding | $2,321 | $1,750 |
American Family vs. Erie: Rates in your state
Insurance rates vary from state to state. Carriers factor in data from your region and ZIP code, including weather, crime and traffic trends to calculate risk. The table below shows where you’ll find the cheapest rates for American Family and Erie. Remember, always shop around for multiple quotes as prices will ultimately be determined by your personal situation and driving record in addition to your location.
| State | American Family | Erie |
|---|---|---|
| Delaware | $2,709 | N/A |
| Illinois | N/A | $1,489 |
| Maryland | N/A | $1,685 |
| Nevada | $2,429 | N/A |
| New York | N/A | $1,814 |
| North Carolina | N/A | $1,082 |
| North Dakota | $1,092 | N/A |
| Ohio | N/A | $1,132 |
| Pennsylvania | N/A | $1,550 |
| Rhode Island | $1,833 | N/A |
| Tennessee | N/A | $1,598 |
| Virginia | N/A | $1,288 |
| Washington | $1,750 | N/A |
| Washington, D.C. | N/A | $1,581 |
| West Virginia | N/A | $1,709 |
| Wisconsin | N/A | $1,313 |
N/A represents data is not available.
American Family vs. Erie: Which offers better discounts?
Discounts are a big draw for customers and can offer significant savings on your annual premiums. Below are some of the discounts American Family and Erie offer to their customers.
| Discounts | American Family | Erie |
|---|---|---|
| Multi Policy | 9% | 8% |
| Payment Type | 9% | 9% |
| Days Advanced Purchase | 8% | 8% |
| Lower Annual Mileage | 3% | 7% |
| Daily Commute | 6% | 7% |
| Loyalty - Years Renewal With Company | 5% | 7% |
| Primary Use | 7% | 17% |
| Days Per Week Driven | 6% | N/A |
| Marital Status | 11% | 6% |
| Paperless/Electornic Documents | 5% | N/A |
| Electronic Funds Transfer | 5% | N/A |
| Homeowner | 4% | N/A |
| Years Licensed | 35% | 26% |
| Safety Devices | 2% | 2% |
| Air Bags | 2% | 1% |
| Years Insured | 14% | N/A |
| Anti-Theft Device | 1% | 1% |
N/A represents data is not available.
Always be sure to ask about available discounts when you’re shopping around for insurance to see what you may qualify for.
American Family vs. Erie: The bottom line
Both American Family and Erie are solid insurance companies, but if rates are what matter most to you, Erie may be the choice for you. However, we always recommend considering more than just rates to find the best car insurance for your needs and comparing quotes from multiple companies.
Methodology
Insurance.com commissioned car insurance rates from Quadrant Data Services for state minimum coverage and full coverage with liability limits of 100/300/100 with $500 deductibles. Base sample rates are based on a 40-year-old male driver with a clean record and good credit driving a 2023 Honda Accord LX. Rates were also fielded for multiple age groups and driver profiles compared with the base sample rate.
Company ratings were gathered from third-party sources including J.D. Power, AM Best and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). We also gathered data from the Insure.com annual survey of car insurance customers.
Helpful auto insurance tools and calculators
